Post by lemon11213 on Jul 27, 2014 20:11:23 GMT -5
celebritytypes.com defines Andrew as an INFP and Emma as an ENFJ.
As I notice carefully, I see Andrew has a wide smile and towards to the ears then he should have Fe smile. Likewise, Emma has vert heavy Fi tension but if she is ENFJ then she should have Fe smile.
Oh and I have a question: when we say, for example: Andrew is a NiFe. Do we mean his dominant and auxiliary function in MBTI?
No. CT is a completely independent theory/model and doesn't draw on anything from MBTI. As such you can't transfer your knowledge from MBTI to CT directly. You have to read the CT material that is available on the site if you want to learn about CT. In CT each person only has 4 functions for example, while in MBTI you supposedly have 8.
In CT the first function (in this case Ni) is called the lead function and is used to indicate both Ni and the polar function of Se, since they work as a pair. The second function of Fe is similar used to indicate both Fe and Ti since they also work as a pair.
Last Edit: Jul 28, 2014 20:37:37 GMT -5 by TheLogicFan
Post by At-Ease Zazeef on Jul 29, 2014 15:01:14 GMT -5
Erifrail typed Andrew Garfield as FiNe here, though I haven't formulated an opinion on him myself. Will get back with that and a read on Ms. Stone sometime soon, though a preliminary quick read on her does suggest SeFi. Yerp.
Erifrail typed Andrew Garfield as FiNe here, though I haven't formulated an opinion on him myself.
Yeah, Auburn mistyped him for some reason. Andrew Garfield couldn't be further from a FiNe in my opinion. He is one of the clearest NiFe examples that I have ever typed. He pretty much radiates Fe in everything he does and his other functions are equally clear.
Last Edit: Jul 29, 2014 16:04:42 GMT -5 by TheLogicFan
Very interesting. I was recently thinking Tobey was NiFe. Andrew does look like an NiFe too.
Very strange that they picked the same type to be spider-man, yet the portrayals are so different. Haha
"I will never assert that an individual must be the type I think they are. I am human, I still have subjectivity. I also think it's possible that an individual can be aware if they have been mistyped. Therefore, when it comes down to it, the ultimate decision to accept/reject a typing should come from that person themself. For better or worse, it is ultimately up to them...or some kind of perfect brain scan. haha"
-IluvHSJ
Very interesting. I was recently thinking Tobey was NiFe. Andrew does look like an NiFe too.
Very strange that they picked the same type to be spider-man, yet the portrayals are so different. Haha
Tobey Maguire does use Se/Ni, but he isn't a NiFe. He is actually quite different from Andrew Garfield. He doesn't have any sign of Fe/Ti. Tobey is a FiSe.
I do agree about Andrew. I'm really not sure why he's typed as Fi, especially Fi-leading. I've stayed very far away from Tobey, seeing how he's had a vote from every Quadra and too many conflicting interpretations of a thing gives me headaches.
Very interesting. I was recently thinking Tobey was NiFe. Andrew does look like an NiFe too.
Very strange that they picked the same type to be spider-man, yet the portrayals are so different. Haha
Tobey Maguire does use Se/Ni, but he isn't a NiFe. He is actually quite different from Andrew Garfield.Β He doesn't have any sign of Fe/Ti. Tobey is aΒ FiSe.
Good call! I looked at more vids and saw his Fi tension more clearly. No wonder the two spideys had a different feel.
"I will never assert that an individual must be the type I think they are. I am human, I still have subjectivity. I also think it's possible that an individual can be aware if they have been mistyped. Therefore, when it comes down to it, the ultimate decision to accept/reject a typing should come from that person themself. For better or worse, it is ultimately up to them...or some kind of perfect brain scan. haha"
-IluvHSJ
Post by The Doctor on Jan 20, 2015 16:45:56 GMT -5
Edit: I have since changed my mind about Emme Stone, and am going with TeNi.
This is a really good learning opportunity, as both of them have slight static feature leanings that might confuse visual typing.
Garfield is doing this (Fe/Ti):
Emma is doing this (Te/Fi):
Next up, Watch their hands and arm movements. Emma does more Je than Ji, and she has tense wrists and fingers. Meanwhile, Andrew's frequently doing Ti puppeteer fingers. Her emphasis is on the arm (Je). His is on the fingers (Ti).
Lastly, their eyebrow movements are both very clearly Se over Si.
Here's an example of how Se pulls from the middle of the eyebrow up and away from the center of the face - THEN - the center:
Compared to how Si pulls to the center:
Note: Ryan Gosling is another classic example of how physical features can conflict with movements. He has 'peaks' in his eyebrows, but his face doesn't move from the peaks. It moves from the center of the brow, up, down, or to pull together (Si/Ne). Also notice the smile tension is in the cheeks near the nose more than moving toward the ears (Fi/Te).
Here's an Si auxiliary example ^
With Fe lead (pulling to the ears) mixing into what Si does, the end result is different than when Si mixes with Fi/Te.
As a Je lead, Tom can sometimes go all the way into a Te effect (smile lines deepening and upper lip raising) when he can't smile wider. But, the thing to note is the MOTION, and even then the 'circular' spread isn't there.
Here's an example of that 'circular' spread moving into a Te effect. If you look closely at how the lips are pulling, you will see that the muscles directly around her mouth are what's making the smile open, not the V effect pushing up from the chin like we see in Hiddleston:
Fe spreads to the ears from the chin without Fi/Te spreading open.
Se spreads eyebrows at the 'peaks' without Si pulls to the center, as both are Ni > Se.
Fe fluid wrists. Ti puppeteer fingers. Te stiff wrists and fingers, moving from the elbows.
Lastly, the known 'fatal' attraction between ENTJ and INFP explain the attraction and failure of Stone-Gosling. Meanwhile ENTJ + INFJ have a natural unspoken chemistry. Watching the two of them is an exercise in Ni/Se conversational shorthand fueled by the Fi+Fe positive and negative charges.
Last Edit: Feb 18, 2016 2:55:44 GMT -5 by The Doctor
Disclaimer: Everything I say here is my OPINION. Please keep that in mind.