Post by Heron on Jun 22, 2013 15:19:12 GMT -5
Hi, in this thread we want to make a list of composers, to find if ther's any correlation with music and CT/CF, in my signature ther's the list with all the composers we found for the moment, is absolutely not a serious thing, is most a recreational activity. We choose only artists who are composers (soundtrack classic) songwriters, and in the case of the groups the ones who have a certain "central mind" in it. Is better to avoid purely pop/commercial artists, because they follow the music trends and business so is difficult to say if a song is sincere or not.
If you want to collaborate feel free to propose or read the ones we're analyzing, if you want to collaborate, i suggest you to make a document in google dock for a good avaiability of your opinions.
I wrote some "guidelines", feel free not to follow them , I think is a good idea to organize the document like this to be easier to read and find one determined type or person more rapidly, and just to make you less scared, you don't have to write a bible, write only what you believe is necessary:
First, make a document in "google dock" (the same i used for the list) for a better availability, suddivided in chapters, each chapters will contain 4 types, listed by common functions, the name for convenience will be the socionics one: alpha (TiNe, FeNi ect), beta (SeTi, NiFe ect), gamma (TeNi, FiSe etc), delta (NeFi, SiTe etc), then in alphabetical order the types, under the types, still in alphabetical order the composers, write also if you agree with the type agreed by the majority.
The criteria:
first: analisys of the career (what genres, most important works), this specifically for the composers, is nearly impossible to write it for a type in general.
Second: analysis of the style (arrangments, tendencies in the composition),
Third: personal opinions (what kind of feelings gives to you, "do you like him?")
Example:
Say your opinions on these guys
Hans Zimmer: If you want to collaborate feel free to propose or read the ones we're analyzing, if you want to collaborate, i suggest you to make a document in google dock for a good avaiability of your opinions.
I wrote some "guidelines", feel free not to follow them , I think is a good idea to organize the document like this to be easier to read and find one determined type or person more rapidly, and just to make you less scared, you don't have to write a bible, write only what you believe is necessary:
First, make a document in "google dock" (the same i used for the list) for a better availability, suddivided in chapters, each chapters will contain 4 types, listed by common functions, the name for convenience will be the socionics one: alpha (TiNe, FeNi ect), beta (SeTi, NiFe ect), gamma (TeNi, FiSe etc), delta (NeFi, SiTe etc), then in alphabetical order the types, under the types, still in alphabetical order the composers, write also if you agree with the type agreed by the majority.
The criteria:
first: analisys of the career (what genres, most important works), this specifically for the composers, is nearly impossible to write it for a type in general.
Second: analysis of the style (arrangments, tendencies in the composition),
Third: personal opinions (what kind of feelings gives to you, "do you like him?")
Example:
Heron's Composers Types Impressions
Alpha:
Heron (i agree with the type) or (i don't agree with the type: SeFi):
Analysis of the Career:
He did some pankakes.
Analysis of the style:
He does not puts eggs and milk because he's vegan, he replaces them cornstarch and rice milk.
Personal opinions:
They had a nice taste.
Alpha:
Analysis of the overall styles:
They are very kzaart and less bzoord
Personal opinions:
They need more atchuum.
NeTi :They are very kzaart and less bzoord
Personal opinions:
They need more atchuum.
Analysis of the overall styles:
They play every instrument, very badly.
Personal opinions:
I love how they cook
They play every instrument, very badly.
Personal opinions:
I love how they cook
Heron (i agree with the type) or (i don't agree with the type: SeFi):
He did some pankakes.
Analysis of the style:
He does not puts eggs and milk because he's vegan, he replaces them cornstarch and rice milk.
Personal opinions:
They had a nice taste.
Say your opinions on these guys
I'm pretty sure he uses Ti/Fe. For some reasons i think He must be Je or Pe, i'm more for the second hypotesis because his approach in music seems the "explorer" one, even his music is more Mood-centered, focused on linkages and arrangements. I think SeTi or NeTi, more for the second.
John Williams:
I think he is Fi lead, he seems to have the airy/delicate voice. I was in trouble with the P functions, but i do think he uses Se/Ni, i can see some heavy scowling during the interview, they seems more Ni than Si.
Jerry Goldsmith:
Pretty sure he uses Te/Fi, but for me he is a P lead. Again, i'm in trouble with the P functions, he is very old in the majority of the interviews, but i do think he uses Ne/Si. I'm in trouble with the order, NeFi?
Basil Poledouris:
For me the P's are Ne/Si. What about FiNe?