oooh good we have too much composers who pummels each others to be read D: anyway, watching the other videos (and updating the list), i'll edit this post later
Edit: PJ harvey: Yez, to me she seems TiSe , in the first video she blinks a lot like Stewart in some interviews, but it can be because she's a Ti lead or just embarassment, she didn't seemed really at ease The eyes goes pretty everywere but her Se is higher than Ni, so for me TiSe.
Bjork: i wonder why i didn't put her in the "queued" list. I see that you're agreeing with Ne/Si as P function. But i found an interview where she does a "lock, drift" like game:
A a bit strange, her articulation reminds a bit yours, i think you have another point in the Fi hypothesis, but for me Fe is still the strong one
Beck: I agree with TiSe, heavy lock on the interviewer, differently from pjh he doesn't drift too much. He seems in a perennial semi-lemur-eyeball state.
@morsecode And what do you think of the other composers? Kozelek, Tim Buckley and Newman? :3 (i don't ask you about jeff because i know your answer about ) i think is better to proceed step by step with 5 (less or more) composers at time, otherwise there is too much confusion D:
And I see that Laura Marling deserves a place with Philip Glass with the Tough ones
Heron - I see what you mean. I think her other body language is different (particularly the eyebrows), but her articulation is a bit like mine. And yes, I am a confusing one. ^_^ We will see. I definitely think I need the consensus system. And I agree with Ne/Si, although I'm not sure about judging functions.
Post by ayoungspirit on Jul 8, 2013 15:21:41 GMT -5
@morsecode : after seeing more video, I agree, PJ Harvey does very heavy pausing and has in fact a very dull face (like Stewart) in some pictures, this must have to do with bone conformity. I say TiSe too.
I'll give it a try to practice my VR abilities. I'll use this post to show my readings.
Laura Marling Tricky girl. I go back and forth with FiTe and TiFe, but I favor FiTe. NiSe, in pictures is more obvious (and in the videos below). JiPe or PiJe or an enigma. Just look at other interviews to be more confused.
Now, I'm thinking she is a NiJe. Posibly a NiFe, despite all the tension (or due to) ... Suddenly losing my credibility hahaha xD
Mark Kozelek I don't think we can know. He reminded me of Beth Gibbons that also doesn't like to appear in interviews. I abstain.
Tim Buckley In the video I saw SiNe and in pictures I see Fe wide smiles. He reminds me of James Franco. SiFe?
Jeff Buckley P-lead, NeSi. Self-parody in some interviews. Flat cheeks, halting, precision. NeTi sounds fine. (but....)
Thomas Newman Definitely NeJi, his smiles trick me, but his speech quickness and giddy nature makes me think FiTe (like Björk that also has that wide smiles, but his look like puppy smiles :3). NeFi.
Last Edit: Jul 9, 2013 8:43:33 GMT -5 by NingenExp
chaoticbrain for me she doesn't seem Fe lead. Too much activity in the upper side of the mouth, really in tension, and she does some asimmetrical expressions...
For me she is a SeFi, she does a lot of explorations but not in a scattered way like a Ne can be, and her perpectually-open mouth shouts a great attention on what happens around her (words or actions). Great display of "Lemur-eyes" also. (i wished i could punch the interviewer in the face. that voice... graah.)
Hey, some others about Joanna? Tomorrow i'll put some other composers to reduce the queued list. I think we found an interesting thing, with the data we have now the FiSe people confirms the stereotypes about their artistic nature, but apparently the most populated block by composers is the NeFi block, and this is interesting, considering that from the mbti statistics the most "artistic functions" in the musical-harmonic sense are Si, Fi, Ni and Fe.