Post by seekerselfdiscovery on Nov 6, 2013 8:54:59 GMT -5
Really, sitbone? You could just say you disagree, without the insults. Not to mention I hope the picture was for comedic purposes only. Seriously, Carl Jung is awesome, but main stream phycology constantly criticizes him, and many people heard of him through MBTI. I'd be surprised if most if not all of you heard of Jung's work on type, through MBTI. If any of you heard of this through someone on the site, chances are they heard of MBTI first. If MBTI is so wrong, why did you waste your time pursuing it, long enough to discover Jung's ultimate truth. Also it's hypocritical, because this is also a twist off Jung's theory. If that was anything other than a joke, than all your info must come strait from Jung purists, at least in their eyes.
Really, sitbone? You could just say you disagree, without the insults. Not to mention I hope the picture was for comedic purposes only. Seriously, Carl Jung is awesome, but main stream phycology constantly criticizes him, and many people heard of him through MBTI. I'd be surprised if most if not all of you heard of Jung's work on type, through MBTI. If any of you heard of this through someone on the site, chances are they heard of MBTI first. If MBTI is so wrong, why did you waste your time pursuing it, long enough to discover Jung's ultimate truth. Also it's hypocritical, because this is also a twist off Jung's theory. If that was anything other than a joke, than all your info must come strait from Jung purists, at least in their eyes.
Is it really Se-toggling she is doing? Or are they for the most Ni-drifts, which she rapidly and constantly breaks because she wishes to articulate and remain eye-contact with the interviewer?
Post by seekerselfdiscovery on Nov 9, 2013 5:43:11 GMT -5
Sitbone, I just think you can criticize the theory, with out calling those who believe in it jokers. I also don't think MBTI ruined Jung's reputation for reasons I stated. I'm also not sure how them expanding on his theory would anyways. People are still free to learn his original work on the theory, and, choose how to implement it, as shown here. Nothing wrong with criticism, critique, and question, but maybe, with out such a negative tone. Also I kind of sensed humor. Although, I sensed some truth, in you were a little put off by MBTI. It wasn't even to you specifically if it was just a joke. I also didn't mean any personal insults, even if you believed that. Many may take it seriously, and I was dispelling anything someone did. I should worry if it wasn't a joke. I just want to make sure people are aren't missing info whenever I can. Also even if you don't agree with MBTI or Kersey(NF, or idealist descriptions) maybe they might help you understand my response, *sniffles* He called me a joker. <-- Exaggeration, just trying to make light, but really we are very sensitive. I wasn't personally offended, but a little put off by the tone.